Learning Methods

From Academic Probation to A+ Average — What Actually Changed

Clock Icon - Consultant Webflow Template
8

From Academic Probation to A+ Average — What Actually Changed

(watch the full Youtube video here: https://youtu.be/fSHpFt7Vt2M?si=HhwFA9rpU4R5Jlxg )

I don't bring this up often, but in my first year of university, I failed half my classes. Not one or two — six. The email from my study counsellor was polite but clear: I was on the academic probation list, and I should consider whether I wanted to continue the programme.

What made it worse was that I genuinely thought I was working hard. I wasn't skipping lectures. I wasn't partying every weekend. I was sitting at the kitchen table for hours each day, convinced I was putting in the effort. And yet, nothing was working.

"I saw peers casually mention their marks and say, 'Oh yeah, I passed.' And I started thinking there was something fundamentally wrong with me."

Eventually, with my parents' support, I found a study coach — which, a decade later, inspired me to do the same work for others. And I did manage to make a genuine shift: from academic probation to performing at a level I hadn't thought possible. This article is the breakdown I wish someone had given me back then.

Why I Was Actually Failing

The biggest mistake I made was spending months trying to fix the wrong problems. I thought I needed more hours, more discipline, more studying. What I actually needed was to understand why I was failing in the first place.

The Fluency Illusion

I was rereading notes. Highlighting entire paragraphs. Listening to recorded lectures for a second time. Making summaries of summaries. All of it felt productive. None of it was.

There's a well-documented cognitive phenomenon called the fluency illusion. When you reread material, your brain recognises it — and recognition feels like knowledge. But an exam doesn't ask you to recognise information. It asks you to retrieve it from memory, organise it, and apply it under pressure. I had never once trained that skill.

Research consistently shows that practising retrieval from memory produces significantly stronger memory pathways than passive review. But nobody teaches us this. Between the ages of 5 and 22, we spend roughly 13,000 hours in formal education — and almost none of it teaches us how to actually learn.

No System, No Structure

My study schedule was: sit down, open whatever felt most urgent, study until tired, go to bed. There was no prioritisation, no time-blocking, no active recall, no spaced repetition. I studied the subjects I liked most and avoided the ones I found difficult — so my weak subjects just kept getting weaker.

I also assumed I was busier than I was. A lot of my "busy" time was scrolling, gaming, or doing anything except the actual work. Without a system, I was making dozens of small decisions every day — and by the time I sat down to study, I was mentally exhausted before I'd opened a single page.

Failing Alone

I didn't go to professor office hours. I didn't form study groups. I didn't ask for help — partly from ego (I was 17), and partly from shame. I believed that needing help meant I wasn't capable.

That belief was exactly backwards. The students performing well around me weren't necessarily smarter. They were more connected. They shared notes, quizzed each other, went for tutoring, and treated studying like a team sport. When you fail alone, you overthink alone — with no one to spot your blind spots.

The Four Changes That Made the Difference

1. Replace Passive Learning with Active RecallStop rereading and highlighting. Start testing yourself on everything — flashcards, quizzes, practice papers, and "blurting" (closing your notes and writing down everything you can remember). It's uncomfortable. It's also the most effective thing you can do.

2. Build a Real Study SystemEvery Sunday: map out your week. When I did this properly, I discovered I had 35 hours of usable study time I was wasting on decision fatigue. Give your hardest time blocks to your weakest subjects. Do deep work in the morning; save review and testing for the evenings.

3. Build a Support SystemStart attending office hours with prepared questions. Find peers who are ahead of you and study with them. And if you can, start teaching students who are behind you — teaching reveals exactly what you don't actually understand yet.

4. Rebuild Confidence Through Small WinsDon't aim for straight A's. Aim to pass one subject you're currently failing. That one pass gives your brain proof the methods work. Small wins compound. Keeping a simple log of what you studied and what the results were will replace the negative internal voice with actual data.

If You're In This Position Right Now

Stop. Diagnose. Then act. Don't add more hours of the same broken approach. Ask yourself honestly: is it your methods? Your schedule? Your mental health? Your environment? You cannot fix a problem you haven't correctly identified.

Your methods are probably the problem. If you're rereading, highlighting, or cramming, you're using the least effective study techniques available. Switch to active recall, spaced repetition, practice testing, and the SQ3R method. These aren't advanced strategies — they're the baseline.

Tell someone you're struggling. A friend, a family member, a counsellor, a professor. Not for sympathy — for accountability. Failing in isolation compounds the shame and makes everything harder. Saying it out loud is the first step toward turning it around.

Shrink your goals dramatically. If you're at a 2.4 GPA, don't aim for the dean's list. Aim to pass one subject you're currently failing. Build the evidence, build the confidence, then move forward from there.

Get professional support if you need it. Failing affects your sleep, your motivation, and your mental health. A study coach or university counsellor can help you fix root causes — not just symptoms — in a fraction of the time it takes alone.

Your grades do not define you. Nobody will ask about your first-year results in five years. What matters is the trajectory. I went from failing six courses to performing at a level I genuinely didn't think was possible — not because I got smarter, but because I stopped using broken methods.

Tom Vorselen

Study Coach

My name is Tom Vorselen, based in Amsterdam, The Netherlands. I help students with scientifically proven learning methods, time management techniques and mindset skills